1871 – 1875

Father Nicholas Byrne

1875 – 1877

Father William J. Seymour

1877 – 1884

Father T.C. Murphy

1884 – 1898

Father Joseph G. Hendrick

1898 – 1911

Father Malachy Garvey

1911 – 1915

Father Michael J. Kreig

1915 – 1929

Father George T. McCall

1929 – 1935

Father John A. Smith

1935 – 1941

Father Emmet F. McGee

1941 – 1947

Father Patrick A. Kelly

1947 – 1947

Father A. Adamek

1947 – 1955

Father John F. Woloch

1955 – 1961

Father J. Joseph O’Connell

1961 – 1965

Father Walter Carron

1965 – 1967

Father Paul Wohlrab

1967 – 1987

Father Vincent LeFrois

1987 – 1994

Father Michael Hogan

1994 – 2003

Father Edward Zenkel

2003 – 2007

Father Richard Shatzel

2007 

Father John Hayes